Maple RRSP

RRSP or TFSA first? The answer is your tax rate today versus your tax rate in retirement. Type your numbers and see both paths, in after-tax dollars, at retirement.

Free · No signup · Nothing you type leaves your browser · 2026 CRA limits & Ontario brackets

Your numbers

Defaults are the worked example below, so the first numbers you see are already checked.

The verdict

After-tax value at retirement, same dollars in

—

—
RRSP path (after tax at retirement)—
TFSA path (tax-free at retirement)—
Difference—
Your marginal tax rate today—
Your marginal tax rate in retirement—
Break-even retirement rate—
Tax refund from the RRSP contribution—
Out of pocket today (either path)—

—

—

Your 2026 contribution room

New RRSP room for 2026—
New TFSA room for 2026—

RRSP room is 18% of your 2025 earned income, capped at $33,810 — before any pension adjustment and before unused room carried forward. Your exact number is on your CRA Notice of Assessment. TFSA room is $7,000 of new room for 2026; $109,000 cumulative if you have been eligible since 2009 and never contributed.

How the math works (2026 rules)

  1. Your marginal rate: the tax on your next $1,000 of income, from the real 2026 brackets — federal 14% to $58,523, 20.5% to $117,045, 26% to $181,440, 29% to $258,482, 33% above; Ontario 5.05% to $53,891, 9.15% to $107,785, 11.16% to $150,000, 12.16% to $220,000, 13.16% above — plus the Ontario surtax (20% of provincial tax above $5,818, and a further 36% above $7,446) and the basic personal amounts (federal $16,452, Ontario $12,989). Income tax only — CPP, EI and the Ontario Health Premium are not included.
  2. The RRSP path: your contribution + any employer match grows tax-free, then you pay tax on the whole withdrawal at your retirement rate. What it costs you today is the contribution minus the refund — the refund is your marginal rate × your contribution.
  3. The TFSA path: you pay tax on the money first, invest what's left, and it grows and comes out completely tax-free. Same out-of-pocket cost today as the RRSP.
  4. The rule that decides it: if your retirement rate is lower than today's rate, the RRSP wins. If it's higher, the TFSA wins. If they're equal, it's a tie on dollars — and the TFSA still wins on flexibility, because you can withdraw any time with no tax and no lost room (room comes back the next January 1).
  5. The break-even rate is the retirement tax rate at which both paths give you exactly the same after-tax dollars. With no employer match it equals your rate today. A match pushes it up — with a 100% match, the RRSP wins unless your retirement rate is above ~65%.
  6. The deadline: RRSP contributions for the 2026 tax year must be made by March 1, 2027 (the first 60 days of 2027). TFSA contributions have no deadline — room just carries forward.
  7. What this leaves out: pension adjustments, unused room carried forward, the $2,000 lifetime RRSP over-contribution cushion, OAS clawback (starts around $93,454 of net income for 2025), GIS effects for low-income retirees, and the FHSA ($8,000/year, $40,000 lifetime for first-time home buyers) — which usually beats both for a first home.

Worked example (the defaults): $75,000 income, $5,000 to invest, 25 years, 5% return, $50,000 retirement income, no match. Your rate today is 29.65% (20.5% federal + 9.15% Ontario); in retirement it's 19.05% (14% + 5.05%). Growth factor 1.0525 = 3.3864. RRSP: $5,000 × 3.3864 × (1 − 0.1905) = $13,706.27 after tax. TFSA: $5,000 × (1 − 0.2965) = $3,517.50 invested × 3.3864 = $11,911.50 tax-free. The RRSP wins by $1,794.77, and the refund is $1,482.50 — so the same $3,517.50 out of your pocket buys $5,000 of RRSP room.

Worked example 2 — the tie: same $75,000 earner, but retiring on $75,000 too. Both rates are 29.65%, so both paths land on $11,911.50 after tax. The tie-breaker is flexibility: the TFSA wins because withdrawals are tax-free and never trigger a tax bill in a high-income year.

Worked example 3 — the flip: a $50,000 earner (19.05% today) who expects $120,000 in retirement (43.41%: 26% federal + 11.16% Ontario + both Ontario surtax tiers). Same $5,000, 25 years at 5%: RRSP $5,000 × 3.3864 × (1 − 0.4341) = $9,581.76; TFSA $5,000 × 0.8095 × 3.3864 = $13,706.27. The TFSA wins by $4,124.51 — a lower rate today than in retirement flips the answer.

Worked example 4 — the match: the $75,000 earner again, but the employer matches 100% of the $5,000. RRSP: $10,000 × 3.3864 × 0.8095 = $27,412.54 after tax, against the TFSA's $11,911.48. The break-even retirement rate jumps to 64.83% — no realistic retirement income taxes that high, so with a full match the RRSP is the answer before you even check the rates.

Rates verified November 12, 2026 against CRA-published 2026 brackets (federal 14%–33%, BPA $16,452) and Ontario's 2026 brackets (5.05%–13.16%, BPA $12,989, surtax thresholds $5,818/$7,446), cross-checked against published Ontario marginal-rate tables (29.65% at $75,000, 31.48% at $100,000, 53.53% top rate). Contribution limits: RRSP $33,810 for 2026 (18% of 2025 earned income), TFSA $7,000 for 2026, $109,000 cumulative since 2009. A planning estimate, not tax or financial advice: your Notice of Assessment is the authority on your room, and a licensed professional should confirm any decision that moves real money.

Not on this page: this compares one lump sum invested once. If you contribute every year, the same rule applies to each year's dollars — and your RRSP withdrawals in retirement are what set your retirement rate, so large RRSP balances can push that rate up. The TFSA has no such feedback loop.